Review: The Tulip Factory by Kacie Davis Idol


I loved waitress-turned-receptionist-turned-successful-you’ll-find-out Corinne. And I loved James, student of the school of hard knocks, climbing his way up and out and free. 

Though I liked the characters and the trajectories Kacie Davis Idol wrote for them, I struggled with some technical aspects of this book:

  • I don’t like chapters that alternate narrators, but I can get over it… unless the author also uses flashbacks and flash-forwards. One or the other may have worked. As it stands it’s confusing for the reader. 
  • The author took up pages and pages describing things that didn’t move the plot forward: Corinne’s outfits, her sister’s wedding, that night at the bar… If it doesn’t add to character or plot development, it’s not needed. Once I realized the chapters were 80% extraneous, I started to skim over the pages of irrelevant details. 
  • The tone for James was inconsistent. Sometimes his chapters made him sound like a sensitive, artistic, loving guy. Other chapters made him seem callous and cold. I’m not sure a man crassly talks about his “kid” one minute and then says he’s in love with the baby a few moments later. 

I think this book has promise. With some paring down of details, reformatting of the order of the chapters, and an editor helping with consistency, The Tulip Factory would have been an enjoyable cute coming-into-her-own story. 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Review: The Tulip Factory by Kacie Davis Idol

  1. The book did have a professional editor….Girl Friday Productions. It was not self published. I like detail in a book….it helps me visualize the setting and the people and the events. As for the alternating narrators….that has been done many times in very successful books and helps show both sides of a relationship. And James….well all men can have differing moods, no guy is wonderful all the time….I believe it just showed a real personality rather than a “fairy tale prince”. It left me wanting to know what happens next and was so easy to identify with. Any woman of any age can relate to this situation because life has it’s ups and downs and is not a fairy tale.

    • I agree that alternating narrators has been done in successful books. I just thought in this book it was too much combined with the flashbacks and flash forwards. We all have different reading tastes… this is just one reviewer’s opinion. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s